Building a Successful Jail Starts with Culture:
The Cornerstone of Effective Jail Management
Chad Wicker
A jail is more than bricks and bars. It is a dynamic, often volatile environment governed not just by policies and procedures, but by people who live and work within its walls. While procedures and physical security are foundational, the culture within a facility ultimately determines whether it operates successfully or spirals into dysfunction. Building and sustaining a positive jail culture is not just a leadership preference; it is a management imperative.
Defining Jail Culture
Culture, simply put, is the shared set of values, beliefs, and behavioral norms that shape how people interact in an environment. In a jail setting, culture influences everything: from how officers treat incarcerated individuals, to how incarcerated individuals respond to authority, to how staff work together under stress. A positive jail culture promotes safety, professionalism, and order. A toxic one breeds distrust, complacency, violence, and liability.
Culture is not built overnight, and it does not emerge by chance. It is the product of intentional leadership, consistent standards, and a shared sense of purpose.
The Pillars of a Positive Jail Culture
1. Leadership by Example
Correctional staff emulate what they see from the top. If administrators cut corners, tolerate disrespect, or fail to enforce accountability, these behaviors cascade downward. Leaders must demonstrate integrity, fairness, and professionalism in every decision. Staff watch closely. Incarcerated individuals watch even closer. Culture is caught, not just taught.
A successful jail administrator must be more than a manager; they must be a cultural architect, shaping the climate through mission clarity and unwavering commitment to ethical standards.
2. Communication and Transparency
A silent jail is not a safe jail. In successful facilities, communication flows freely among leadership, staff, and, in appropriate ways, incarcerated individuals. This includes daily briefings, open-door policies, and clear communication of expectations and policy changes. Staff should feel empowered to voice concerns, offer suggestions, and report misconduct without fear of retaliation.
Transparency creates trust. And trust, especially in the correctional setting, is the currency that buys compliance, loyalty, and long-term staff retention.
3. Professionalism and Staff Development
A professional culture starts with competent, confident staff. Ongoing training is essential, not just for technical skills, but for interpersonal skills, de-escalation techniques, and legal awareness. Staff who are well-trained are less likely to use force inappropriately, more likely to respond effectively to crises, and more invested in their roles.
Beyond training, staff must be treated as professionals. That means investing in their growth, listening to their ideas, and holding them accountable in fair and consistent ways.
4. Incarcerated Individual Accountability Coupled with Dignity
A jail culture that respects incarcerated individuals’ basic humanity, while holding them firmly accountable for their behavior, is a healthy one. Facilities that allow staff to belittle or dehumanize incarcerated individuals undermine their own authority. Dignity is not softness; it is a strategic approach to gaining cooperation and reducing volatility.
This includes clean housing, timely medical care, access to religious and legal services, and a grievance process that is taken seriously. Programs and incentives for incarcerated individuals reinforce prosocial behavior and reduce idleness, a frequent source of misconduct.
5. Consistency Across Shifts and Staff
Inconsistency destroys credibility. One officer’s tolerance becomes another’s infraction. This fuels grievances, stokes tensions, and encourages incarcerated individuals to manipulate divided staff. Successful jails ensure that expectations, consequences, and responses are consistent across the board, day shift or night, veteran or rookie, floor officer or supervisor.
This requires clear policies, robust supervision, and frontline leaders who are trained not just in task management but in people management.
The Dangers of a Broken Culture
When culture breaks down, the symptoms are swift and severe: spikes in use of force, excessive grievances, burnout, absenteeism, and recruitment failures. A toxic jail culture fosters apathy, cynicism, and eventually corruption. Misconduct flourishes in silence and disunity. Public trust erodes. Litigation follows.
Culture doesn’t stay neutral. It either strengthens with intentionality or decays with neglect.
How to Begin Cultural Reform
Cultural reform doesn’t require a new facility or bloated budget. It starts with a change in mindset and a commitment to purpose. Here are steps administrators can take:
• Conduct a Cultural Audit: Use surveys, interviews, and incident data to assess your current culture. What behaviors are tolerated? What values are lived out?
• Articulate a Vision: Develop a clear mission statement that prioritizes safety, professionalism, and dignity. Make it visible and actionable.
• Train Supervisors First: Culture hinges on mid-level leaders. Invest in supervisory training that emphasizes communication, ethics, and mentoring.
• Recognize Positive Behavior: Celebrate staff who model the desired culture. Recognition builds morale and reinforces standards.
• Address Misconduct Swiftly: A single toxic employee can unravel months of progress. Correct behavior firmly, fairly, and fast.
• Engage the Community: Invite oversight, transparency, and partnerships. A jail that isolates itself becomes insular and defensive. Community collaboration brings perspective, programs, and accountability.
Case Example: Transforming from Crisis to Culture
When I took over operations at the Tate County Detention Facility, we inherited a fragmented culture: low morale, minimal programming, high turnover, and uneven enforcement of policy. Within the first year, we implemented daily briefings, started peer mentoring for new staff, and rolled out programming for incarcerated individuals in partnership with local educators and chaplains. We instituted a fair but firm discipline policy for incarcerated individuals and revamped our performance evaluation system for staff.
The result? A 40% reduction in staff turnover, fewer grievances, and a notable improvement in staff-incarcerated individual interaction. Culture didn’t fix everything, but it gave us a foundation on which everything else could be fixed.
Conclusion: Culture is the Mission
A jail will never rise above the character of its culture. No amount of equipment, policy, or technology can compensate for a broken workplace climate. Conversely, even resource-strapped jails can thrive when culture is healthy. The choice is ours: tolerate dysfunction or commit to transformation. Culture is the one force inside a jail that can’t be faked, and the one that ultimately determines success or failure.
________________________________
Chad Wicker is the Director of Detention Services for the Tate County Sheriff’s Office in Mississippi. He is a Certified Jail Manager through the American Jail Association. He holds a Bachelor of Political Science from the University of Mississippi and a Master of Public Administration degree from Arkansas State University. For more information, he can be contacted at cw@rgjail.com
References
American Correctional Association. (2022). Core jail standards. ACA.
Clemmer, D. (1940). The prison community. Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
National Institute of Corrections. (2016). Culture and behavior in the jail. U.S. Department of Justice.
Schein, E. H. (2010). Organizational culture and leadership (4th ed.). Jossey-Bass.
Useem, B., & Kimball, P. (1991). States of siege: U.S. prison riots, 1971–1986. Oxford University Press.